February 4, 2006
Crazy Cocktail Recipe: Scotch and Milk, Baby!
As we were trolling the Web today looking for all things bright and boozy, we came across a cryptic mention of someone making a cocktail out of Scotch and milk. Yes, we're serious.
Not only that, we suddenly were hit with a memory from the liquor-filled crevices in the back of our brains of some poet or another we were forced to read in college mentioning the drink. It sounded like an abomination to us, but we were curious - what would Scotch and milk taste like, and why the hell would someone drink it?
According to our research, the drink is usually taken by people who have ulcers but don't want to cut down on their daily dram. While we find the idea of just depth-charging some milk into our precious Scotch to be a bit revolting, we did find a passable recipe for you ulcer-sufferers (or grown up babies) out there. It's called Scotch Milk Punch, and though we don't have an ulcer, we're preparing ourselves for the day our stomach gives out.
Scotch Milk Punch
2 oz. Scotch
6 oz. Milk
1 tsp. Powdered Sugar
Shake with ice and strain into a collins glass. Garnish with nutmeg.
We used White Horse Scotch and substituted our home-made simple syrup
for the powdered sugar. The drink got quite frothy, and all in all it tastes like a poor man's eggnog or a milk shake for drunks. Also, keep in mind that you don't have to do it only with Scotch; try it with other whiskeys, or you can give it a go with brandy or some other liquor.
Recipe via BarNoneDrinks: Scotch Milk Punch
Update - FYI, we've been feeling more than a little nauseous since we drank this bad boy. And we're not talking "post roller coaster after too many hot dogs" nauseous, either. It's more like the "hey Kane, what's that coming out of your chest?" kind of nausea. We're hoping it's not attributable to the drink, but we thought we should warn you.
Read More in: Cocktail Recipes | Scotch
Share this Article with others:
Came straight to this page? Visit Liquor Snob for all the latest news.
Posted by Jake Jamieson at February 4, 2006 2:44 PM
Scotch and milk is an old Cowboy drink from the 19th century.
In fact, many of your favorite Western Actors would pull up on their horses at Gower Gulch on their lunch breaks from shooting the latest block buster Western... and imbibe this drink in the mid 20s through the 30s.
Cops would also drink this for the reasons that follow:
It works because the milk (cold 1/2 and 1/2) keeps the liquor from going directly to one's head, while you get a light buzz.
In addition, no one ever knows that you're drinking and there's no alcohol on your breath.
That's the actual inside joke of 'clean cut Cowboys drink milk'.
I always chase my shots of J&B with milk
As a follow-up to my scotch and Ensure sleepy time cocktail: didn;t work … tasted good, though!
I am desperate. I've had two surgeries in the last three months and the aftershocks of the anesthesia and the drugs are keeping me wide awake. It is now 2:32 pm.
I googled scotch milk sleep a half-thought from some deep crevice in my brain. I have also lost a lot of weight and am trying to get some back.
Here is the healthy answer from my refrigerator and bar: an 8oz Vanilla Ensure (350 calls and maybe 30-40% of what you need), and some simple syrup. It tasted exactly egg nog!
I am writing this before going back to bed. I'll follow-up if it works.
In at least two novels by Joseph Wambaugh he's mentioned this drink. In "The New Centurians" an easygoing cop gets some scotch and milk and cups for the prostitutes in the police wagon so they can have some refreshments before going to jail. They apparently love milk and scotch. And in "The Delta Star" a policeman is questioning an old woman who makes herself a drink out of milk and scotch. He asks her if she has an ulcer and she says, no: "I just like milkballs. Learned it from the colored people in the neighborhood." In Wambaugh's books the drink is called a "milkball." It's apparently a cocktail that appeals to people in a lower income bracket. Anyway, it does sound disgusting.
Use Nestles French vanilla liquid creamer in place of the milk and powder sugar. YUMMMMY. I have drank this drink for the past 40 years, and only recently started using the creamer.
i'm not understanding the babyish repulsion at the thought of scotch and milk!?! and why mention "black prostitutes"???? white folks...
My parents used to make this for New Year's Eve and thus my search for the correct ratios. My dad would crack ice into a blender then mix up the milk and scotch.
Pretty sure this drink is mentioned in James Baldwin's story "Sonny's Blues."
I am a scotch drinker single malt usually. My mother used to drink this when I was small along with something my parents called a "salty Dog" which was gin or vodka with grapefruit juice and salt?? I have never tried scotch and milk but I think I will pick up a bottle of my favorite scotch tomorrow anf give it a go........
We've learned a lot since we wrote this story a few years ago and we'll say - there is a place in the world for a scotch and milk punch.
The people above saying, "disgusting!" also mention that they'll never try it. It's shortsighted, dense, and not at all adventurous to say those things -- far from the attitude someone looking to try new spirits and cocktails should have. If we never ate or imbibed things which lacked an immediate, obvious appeal, none of us would ever have tried lobster either. As others have pointed out above, this drink is similar in some ways to a year-round eggnog sans eggs, especially with a pinch of nutmeg added. With some honey stirred in, it even approaches a desert. One last thing: everything in this drink calms the stomach and there was a time when it was used as a pre-sleep nightcap. The comments by the staff that it made them "more than a little nauseous" is certainly the result of one guy saying it was gross and everyone else bandwagoning. It wouldn't have made everyone in the room sick. Drink with an open mind, LiquorSnob staff, not with a schoolyard mentality.
the great lawrence taylor loved scotch and milk, chivas to be exact
Hey all, I thought that this was something that i had done that was unique, but i guess not. I usually drink it before i go to bed, to help me sleep, Microwave 6oz milk stir in honey and then scotch. I sleep so well after.
just saw christina ricci pour milk into her straight mccallens..in "miranda"
Eggnog without the eggs. Without the poison from bad eggs.
I like scotch and chocolate milk. Already sweet and with chocolatey goodness and the spice of the scotch. There's also a chocolate scotch cake that's pretty good. Like german chocolate with a kick!
Forgot to tell you my recipe: loss the sugar!!!!cupcakes all you need is a glass of ice 5 to 6 cubes 2oz of scotch (always pour your scotch first or it will spoil your milk)then add your cold milk to taste once again enjoy!!
Scotch -n- Milk ONE of my favorites. I'm a young man with no ulcers but i still love the drink.My grandfather use to sit up and watch the ball games with me while sipping his Johnnie walker and milk. FYI the type of scotch matters when it comes to the taste i like johnnie,chivas or dewars!!! enjoy!
In the late 60's I had a co-worker in Boston who said she and her husband both drank it all the time. I've never tried it and I'm not about to.
No mention of Charlie "Bird" Parker? That's where I heard of it. He was a fan of this drink, atleast in his film. If it's not bourbon or rye, why not mix it?
i just saw a scotch and milk being served in a restaraunt on the food network... thats what brought me here.
must be a southern thing i am i thinking
Aahh fellow scotch lovers... the milk and scotch is actually pretty smooth IF you substitute honey for the sugar and the milk is ICE COLD... really ICE COLD! A 9 oz. high ball glass is the perfect size. My recipe (which I erroneously thought I invented)is 1 oz. scotch... go ahead make it a good scotch... add about 6 oz milk... add honey to taste stirring well. If you have room, add more cold milk. This is not unlike a grasshopper or chocolate martini. Using real milk and not skim milk helps, too.
lol, im watching the same csi episode and did the same exact thing, for the same reason. Jinx!
Just thought I'd mention this drink was also mentioned in an episode of CSI which I am watching right now (hence my scotch and milk search which ultimately led me to this page). They suggested that the drink was preferred by those with ulcers too, so as disgusting as this may seem, this drink appears to be a popular one. An acquired taste perhaps?
Scotch and Milk is also found in the short story by James Baldwin, "Sonny's Blues"
The narrator of Vitamins, a story by Raymond Carver, drinks Scotch and milk.
The Dean Koontz novel, "The Door to December," a few pages into chapter 32, has two of the bad guys sitting in a cabin in the Sierras drinking scotch and milk just before the poltergeist gets them.
I was just watching the "New Centurians" on TV and at some point of the movie the Cops pick up a bunch of black prostitutes who all request "scotch and milk"
i came across the simple 'scotch and milk' formula in a short story by Phillip K. Dick, called 'The Pre-Person'. Thought id look it up befor i tryed it, glad i did.
That's just friggin' disgusting.